Jun 24 2009
blinkbox review - Vicky Cristina Barcelona
‘A real return to form’, many said when it came out at the cinema. That Woody Allen had re-found that comical style which captures the absurdity and heartbreak of love that we saw in his golden age of the late 70s and early 80s. Of course, in those days, the films written and directed by him also starred him. We had his lost, slightly charmless intellectual side strangely winning over women way above him on the physical attraction ladder. And that was usually fun to watch. But now at 84, or however old he is, I suppose he can’t play the romantic character he invented so regularly any more. Personally, I was hoping his return to form was in doing more of the ‘orgasmotron’ scenario from Sleeper. Unfortunately not.
This film, Vicky Cristina Barcelona, is a Mills & Boon affair with a delicate sprinkle of wit added from time to time. It’s the tale of two friends going to Barcelona for a couple of months. Obviously, they are Vicky and Cristina. Two American ladies who made friends at university and decided to have a last hurrah before Vicky gets married. They arrive and are quickly invited on a weekend away to Oviedo by the celebrated artist Juan Antonio. He’s played by the ever charming Javier Bardem. I’ve only seen him in a few films, but I generally like what I see. Quite an unorthodox face that’s oddly catching nonetheless. He gets a straight yes from Cristina who is clearly smitten. But Vicky turns down the offer down, thinking of her fiancé.
Of course, both women do fly off with Juan Antonio and romance ensues. Juan Antonio, with his shirt always somewhat open, charms each of them enough to create a love triangle. But, in comes Penelope Cruz as Juan Antonio’s ex-wife and artist Maria Elena. So it’s a love quadrangle now. Who will capture Juan Antonio’s heart for good? Will it be Vicky who for the first time has fallen for the wrong man and is eaten by the guilt of it? Might it be Cristina, whose mind changes regularly and could settle down at last? Or will it be Maria Elena with her fiery Latino temperament and tortured artistic soul finding that calm with her one true love? Frankly, who very much cares. All I do know is that Juan Antonio seems to be living many men’s dream existence. Three beautiful women all yearning to stroke his ego. Perfect.
In olden times, Allen would put together a situation that might have been a little real. You could imagine this speccy little man with uncombed hair in circumstances and with women he didn’t know how to handle. But this was not that. Vicky, played by Rebecca Hall, was supposed to be him. She is wrestling with the love she feels for Juan Antonio and the loyalty she wants to feel for her drab, finance oriented fiancé. She’s high-minded and more normal than the wilder and sexualized Cristina, played by Scarlett Johansson. Lots of people might find me crazy to say it, but I do find Johansson quite boring. And her acting is generally quite characterless too. I didn’t have much time for any of them really.
There are two main points of annoyance in it all though. The first one I might have been a little to blame for. I put the DVD in, but before pressing play decided to do a crossword. Yes, yes, yes I am a bit boring myself, but I like crosswords. Anyway, the crossword was about 12 minutes long, and all the while I had the arty plucking of guitars with a slightly fake Spanish accent crooning over it. By the time I finished and started the film, I was sick of it. Then it kept appearing in the film too. Most annoying.
The other thing was how the story of the film was a voiceover explaining developments as time passed. I never like this in films as it usually makes out we don’t understand what is happening, or can’t make our minds ourselves. I could make my mind up, and found the whole thing a bit uninteresting and not really a return to form. It’s quite a nice travel guide for Barcelona though, so tourists rejoice.

